| Seeking Skilled Care
in the Early Postpartum - Summary |
| Activity/Partner |
| |
The
CHANGE Project partnered with Save the Children/Guinea
to test a model for community-level interventions to increase
the use of early postpartum care for mothers and newborns.
As part of a Community Health Initiative in Guinea, West
Africa, Save the Children is training nurses and traditional
birth attendants (TBAs) to reduce maternal and newborn
deaths. |
| |
| Background |
| |
| The early postpartum period is critical
to both maternal and newborn survival. Skilled attendance
during delivery and adherence to a new schedule of postpartum
care by a skilled provider could reduce both maternal
and newborn deaths in this critical time period. The World
Health Organization (WHO) recommends up to four visits
with new mothers during the early postpartum period. These
visits should take place at one, three, seven and fourteen
days postpartum.
Up to 45% of all maternal deaths occur within one day
of delivery, 65% within the first week and 80% within
the first two weeks after birth. Thus, during the first
24 hours postpartum and the first week after birth,
women are at highest risk for maternal death. The risk
remains significant in the second week postpartum as
well. Hemorrhage, pregnancy-induced hypertension (PIH)
and sepsis are the most common causes of early postpartum
maternal death. As much as 30% of all PIH occurs in
the first days postpartum. The period of greatest risk
for hemorrhage and PIH is during the first day and drops
off steeply after that. Careful attention is needed
during the first 4 to 6 hours, when postpartum hemorrhage
is most likely to occur. Most deaths from sepsis occur
during the second week after delivery.
The early postpartum period is critical to newborn
survival as well. Neonatal mortality now accounts for
approximately two thirds of the eight million annual
deaths worldwide in children under one year of age.
98% of all newborn deaths occur in developing countries,
mainly Africa and Asia. The first week of life is a
particularly vulnerable period, when 50-70% of fatal
and life-threatening newborn illnesses occur. Most of
these newborn deaths are due to sepsis, asphyxia and
problems associated with low birth weight.
Programs should emphasize routine skilled care for
new mothers and newborns that focuses on early detection
of complications and prompt referral, in addition to
the "fortieth day" postpartum visit. It is
a particular challenge to develop early postpartum care
programs that can deliver this lifesaving care in resource-poor
rural areas where a skilled provider rarely attends
even the births. |
| |
| The Early Postpartum
Visitor |
| |
| The global recommendations could be
implemented locally through a variety of options |
| |
Framework
for Early Postpartum Care (EPPC) Options |
Early
Postpartum Visitor |
|
Early
Postpartum Care Stations |
|
Facility-Based
Early Postpartum Care |
|
|
|
|
| |
| Option 1: strengthen the capacity of
skilled providers at facilities to expand the range and
timing of maternal and newborn services to provide several
points of contact during the first two weeks after birth.
Option 2: create or strengthen a cadre of informed,
community early postpartum visitors who can make several
visits into the home of new mothers in the two weeks
after birth to check for danger signs in both mother
and newborn.
Option 3: create an early postpartum care station in
the community, an important option if households are
resistant to an external visitor entering the home during
the culturally-sanctioned isolation during the first
few days after birth. In those cases, a "linkworker"
at the care station could evaluate, refer and accompany
the woman or newborn to skilled care. |
| |
| Objectives |
| |
The main objectives of
this partnership were to:
- Identify factors that contribute to patterns of
early postpartum care seeking behavior among recently
delivered women; and explore the factors underlying
careseeking decisionmaking during the early postpartum
period in remote rural Guinea;
- Test the acceptability among families, community
members and skilled care providers of the concept
of introducing home visitors as "linkworkers"
to skilled early postpartum care; and to determine
their preferred EPPC option (described above);
- Test the feasibility and effectiveness of using
community interviewers to conduct qualitative research;
and
- Actively involve community members in designing
a locally appropriate "community-negotiated"
early postpartum care intervention.
|
| |
| Setting |
| |
| Save the Children's Community Health
Initiative works with the MOH/ Guinea to improve maternal
care in 73 remote rural communities in Mandiana Province,
Haute Guinea, where most of the 200,000 residents belong
to the Malinke ethnic group. Many villages are as far
as 45 kilometers from a health facility. Ninety percent
of urban women and 50% of rural women, live within five
kilometers of a health facility providing delivery care.
The current maternal mortality ratio in Guinea is estimated
at 528 per 100,000 live births. Nationally, skilled
attendants assist 35% of births. About 17% of women
receive any type of postpartum care, including the fortieth
day visit. In urban areas, births are more than three
times as likely to be attended by a skilled provider
than in rural areas. Traditional Birth Attendants (TBAs)
attended slightly more than one third of all births
nationwide. TBAs attend 30% of births, more than three
times as high in Haute Guinea as in other parts of the
country. More than 40% of all births are attended by
a relative or were unattended. No one at all was with
many Guinean women giving birth. In some rural areas,
unattended births are as high as 75%.
Many health facilities do not currently provide basic
care for obstetric emergencies. For appropriate emergency
care, is often necessary to bypass health centers and
go directly to a hospital. For 46% of rural women this
requires an hour or more of travel by vehicle, if a
vehicle is available. The area is sparsely populated
with only nine inhabitants per square kilometer, less
than half the national population density. This increases
the challenge of providing even basic maternity care. |
| |
| Methods |
| |
| Eighty-three people in two sites in
Mandiana Province, Mandiana District (urban, served by
a district hospital) and Koundian District participated
in four focus group discussions (FGDs) and 47 in-depth
interviews (IDIs). One site was near and one site was
far from the District Referral Hospital, the only facility
in the region with the capacity to provide comprehensive
maternal care. Equal numbers were chosen from Mandiana
and Koundian, except for the category of skilled providers.
Five skilled providers were interviewed in Mandiana, and
two skilled providers were interviewed in Koundian. Interviewers
conducted discussions in French with the skilled providers
and in Malinke with the other respondents. |
| |
| Use of Community
Interviewers |
| |
| The research team selected five community
interviewers from Mandiana. The interviewers all had experience
as Save the Children community health "animators."
The team recognized that some respondents might know these
interviewers and that this might influence responses.
The team agreed, however, that the benefits– familiarity
with the area, confidence of the community leaders in
their ability and existing maternal health knowledge -
outweighed the disadvantages.
Save the Children staff trained the interviewers. The
training reviewed the research objectives, discussed
basic concepts of early postpartum care, reviewed the
maternal and newborn health terms that would be "translated"
into local terms and definitions, and provided an overview
of basic interview techniques. Community interviewers
reviewed and translated each research instrument into
Malinke. |
| |
| Key Findings/Program
Implications |
| |
- Many respondents knew several basic obstetric danger
signs. However, awareness of the specific danger signs
during the early postpartum period needed strengthening,
particularly of the most common causes of death during
the early postpartum period for women (hemorrhage,
sepsis and pregnancy-induced hypertension) and newborns
(asphyxia, sepsis and sequelae of low birth weight).
Strategies to increase knowledge of danger signs could
build on existing awareness of dizziness, bleeding
and fever.
- Participants, including skilled attendants and village
health committee members, were willing to learn more
about pregnancy, birth and postpartum and supplied
detailed information on when, where and with whom
they commonly meet to discuss birth-related topics.
- There was limited community awareness about the
need for early postpartum care, especially for mothers.
The research identified a need for a strategy to increase
demand for early postpartum care. Beginning with birth
preparedness plans that include early postpartum care,
the strategy should reinforce early postpartum care
for the mother and newborn. The strategy should be
promoted to women and TBAs and to relatives, since
so many births in Guinea are not attended by TBAs.
There is a belief that the husband/partner has a responsibility
to provide for the birth-related needs of women and
newborns. This belief could reinforce the importance
for men about the need for early postpartum care in
their household.
- There was already a strong cultural tradition surrounding
the postpartum period. Findings emphasized the importance
of building on positive beliefs and practices by integrating
improved behaviors into a framework of accepted beliefs.
For example, the strategy could:
- Reinforce positive aspects of the special waiting
period, such as attention to maternal nutrition
and special care and social support for mother;
- Incorporate specific terms already used by the
community into their understanding of "protection"
of the new mother and baby to include early postpartum
health checks; and
- Select people who did not conflict with taboos
related to the waiting period to perform the routine
early postpartum checking visit for all new mothers
and newborns.
- Potential conflict existed between a culturally
accepted isolation of the mother and newborn and need
for vigilance to detect danger signs during the first
week. The importance of the timing of early postpartum
visits, during the first week when cultural "sanctions"
are still in place, must be made clear to household
members and the early postpartum visitor/link worker.
In-home visits could be promoted as harmonious with
existing birth tradition. Findings highlighted the
need to stress that early postpartum visitors should
visit homes twice before day seven. The seventh day
is an important "transition" time, when
some of the traditional constraints to maternal mobility
can be negotiated. The existing practice of taking
healthy newborns for vaccination on the eighth day
postpartum could be used to promote the equal importance
of checking mothers at the same time. In turn, local
terms regarding newborn immunization should be integrated
into any discussion about early postpartum careseeking
for new mothers.
- The early postpartum care option for routine checks
should incorporate people's preferences that mothers
remain in their homes during the first week after
birth, if possible. Participants noted that early
postpartum visitors could enter homes to check mothers
without violating that important belief. The research
identified the need to reinforce checks should be
made if even there are no problems.
- Participants observed that an appropriate family
member could take mothers and newborns with danger
signs to an early postpartum care station without
violating customs.
- Community members preferred trained TBAs as early
postpartum visitors. The roles of trained TBAs' roles
should be expanded to include routine early postpartum
care and danger signs checks for both mothers and
newborns. At the same time, the role and responsibilities
of other recognized community health workers (village
health committee members, health agents, etc.) need
to be broadened to include monitoring danger signs
in mothers and newborns during the early postpartum
period.
- The strategy should promote skilled careseeking
for complications whenever feasible, and reinforce
the existing belief in seeking care at any time, especially
during the early postpartum period. It should emphasize
that TBAs (both trained and untrained) are a link
to, but not a substitute for, skilled care.
|
| |
| Acceptability
of Proposed Early Postpartum Visitor Concept |
| |
| Community members accepted
the concept of an early postpartum visitor and identified
their conditions of acceptability. Their conditions should
be incorporated into the overall intervention design and
the behavior change strategy, especially those articulated
by women and families regarding the visitor and location.
The strategy should allow clear "options" for
home visits or care stations in the community.
It is important to reinforce the positive characteristics
of skilled providers as perceived by women and their
families. "Trained" was a very important qualifier
used by community members to describe their preferred
early postpartum visitor.
Skilled providers and village health committee members
also overwhelmingly endorsed the concept and shared
guidelines they believed would be necessary for the
intervention to succeed. Their specific suggestions
should be incorporated in the strategy.
Each category of respondent also offered very useful
ideas on how to increase community awareness of the
need for EPPV in their communities, and these should
be incorporated into the dissemination strategy to the
greatest extent possible.
Although many of the findings were similar in urban
and rural locations, some clear differences were notable.
These responses should be considered when developing
the early postpartum visitor intervention and behavior
change strategy.
Differences between Urban and Rural Communities |
| Mandiana
(Urban) |
Koundian
(Rural) |
| Pregnant women talk to their
friends and to trained TBAs about pregnancy
and birth. |
Pregnant women rarely talked to anyone about
their pregnancy and birth. |
| Women tell their husbands first when they
have a problem because it is the husbands
who take charge of the family, especially
in times of crises. |
Women tell their mother-in-law or their
friends if they have problem because they
are the ones who spend the most time with
the new mothers. |
| TBAs are not allowed to administer care
to women. |
TBAs administer care. |
| People prefer trained TBAs to
conduct early postpartum checks. |
People prefer facility-based skilled providers
to conduct early postpartum checks when women
bring their baby for vaccination. |
Skilled providers rarely make
home visits; it is up to the mother to go
to the facility for a consultation.
|
When a woman delivers at the health center,
the health agent who assisted the birth makes
a home visit. |
| Women rarely used traditional
medicine, especially for problems of pregnancy
or delivery. |
Women occasionally use traditional medicine
because it is less expensive and more effective
for certain illnesses. |
| Difficult for new mothers to
make postpartum care visits to facilities
in the first and second weeks after birth. |
Postpartum visits difficult because women
not aware of the importance of early postpartum
consultations after birth. |
| Women are taken to the hospital
to give birth when labor begins. |
Some women are taken to health center; others
continue to deliver at home. |
| Time ranges from 6 to 12 hours
from recognition of complication until taken
to a health facility. |
Time ranges from 10 hours to 3 days from
recognition of complication until taken to
a health facility. |
| Cost for care at health facility
between 13,000 and 200,000 GF. |
Cost for care at health facility between
9,000 to 50,000 GF. |
| Women prefer trained TBAs to
skilled providers because they do their jobs
well and are less expensive. |
Women are embarrassed to go to the health
facilities and lack information on the importance
of skilled care during and after delivery.
|
| When a woman has a complication
"she is operated on" (cesarean). |
When a woman has a complication she is either
treated there or referred to the hospital
in the city. |
| Lack of money often delays skilled
care at the hospital even if it is an emergency.
|
Delays in treatment related to limited obstetric
care available at the health center and transportation
cost and availability of vehicles to reach
referral hospital in the city. |
| When there are problems TBA and family members
must find a way to help transport the new
mother and baby to the hospital. |
When there are problems, skilled provider
is summoned to the home by a TBA to check
on the mother and new baby. |
|
|
| |
| Community Recommendations |
| |
| The CHANGE consultant and Save the Children
staff who participated in the research held participatory
discussions with community members, village health committee
members, skilled providers and the health administration
to present and discuss the findings.
Overall recommendation
- Develop an early postpartum care program that includes
suggestions for criteria, roles and activities of
early postpartum visitors outlined in this study;
particularly the use of trained TBAs as link workers
who would work in close association with the village
health committee and skilled providers.
Strategy Components |
| |
| Communication/Community
Mobilization |
| |
- Develop activities to increase knowledge of danger
signs related to pregnancy and childbearing in the
community (with focus on early postpartum danger signs).
- Develop activities to increase communication between
husbands and their wives during pregnancy, particularly
in preparing for childbirth.
- Increase awareness of the community obstetric emergency
referral system, particularly the importance of families
contributing to the community bank.
- Explore the possibility of expanding the community
bank to include normal delivery instead of just complications.
|
| |
| Social Networks/Communication
Channels |
| |
- Involve the opinion leader of the community (Imam,
mayor and district president) in the early postpartum
care awareness campaigns and sessions.
- Use rural radio as a source of disseminating early
postpartum care information.
Training
- Reinforce the training of both skilled providers
and trained TBAs in terms of early postpartum care.
- Train more TBAs so that all communities have a least
one trained TBA to help women prepare for birth, assist
birth and provide postpartum care.
|
| |
| Systems Strengthening |
| |
- Ensure that all parties involved respect official
tariffs for services and drugs at the health facilities.
- Finalize the contract between the village health
committee, community bank and the referral center
(hospital).
|
| |
| Lessons Learned |
| |
| The results are examples of negotiating
behavior change to improve early postpartum care. Earlier
qualitative research has shown that families and communities
are not always willing to accept new ideas and behaviors
that would require them to alter firmly established childbirth
traditions. Testing new concepts and behaviors before
designing and implementing programs can improve the likelihood
of adoption of recommended behaviors and reduce costly
mistakes.
In Mandiana District, however, respondents expressed
a high degree of willingness to change current behaviors
and to consider alternative early postpartum care options.
Their willingness to change a given practice - early
postpartum care - increases the likelihood of rapid,
measurable behavior change. Respondents had realistic
suggestions about which option would be the most feasible
and how to tailor it to local needs, within the constraints
that exist for both clients and providers.
The results from Mandiana provide an example of research
to support behavior-based programming and community
negotiation. The research results can be directly applied
to behavior change strategy formulation. Community members
began applying the results during community meetings. |
| |
| Adaptations and
Future Uses of Change Tools and Approaches |
| |
| Save the Children has recently
received funding from USAID to continue with the strategy
development, implementation, and evaluation of a behavior-based
early postpartum care program as follow-on to this research
activity.
Tools (Danger Signs
Plus)
Report |
| |
| >> Maternal
Survival Toolkit Home |